Topics:
Crime in the Castro, Formula Retail
Formula Retail Guidelines for Upper Market Street
Chipotle
Attendees: 42
Officers and Board Members attending: Alan Beach-Nelson, President; Rob Cox, Secretary; Gary Weiss, Treasurer; Judy Hoyem; Patrick Crogan; Mary Edna Harrell; Tim Eicher; Aaron Seivertson; Mark McHale
7:05 Welcome and Introductions
Panel Discussion on Crime in the Castro
Moderated by Tim Eicher and Patrick Crogan
Panel Participants: Sister Eve Olution, Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence; John Fitzinger, patrol Special; Sgt Scott Edwards, SFPD; Brian Hill, CCOP
• The panel discussion was proposed because of a perceived increase in property and violent crime in the neighborhood over the past year or so.
• After introductions Tim began by asking about the increasing crime in the neighborhood and asking the panel what the safety organizations (SFPD, CCOP, etc.) were doing to respond and what we as neighbors can do to help make the neighborhood safe.
• There followed a 50-minute discussion and Q & A. Topics discussed and advice given by the pane
o Get involved in the neighborhood and know your neighbors
o Report all crimes all the time
o Use the 911, 311 and SFPD non emergency number, 415-553-0123 and always ask for a CAD number
o John gave a profile of Patrol Special and its role helping the businesses in the neighborhood, how they patrol
o Citizens arrest processes
o Sgt Edwards talked about the increase in plain clothes patrols
o Sister Eve profiled the Stop the Violence campaign. SPI are running a Personal Safety Seminar (check sisters.org for details), Be Safe for Pride campaign
• The best deterrent to the burglaries and muggings in the neighborhood is a community that is involved and informed. Get involved in your neighborhood even at the block level. Know your neighbors and look out for each other.
Formula Retail Guidelines for Upper Market Street
• Pat Tura, DTNA, spoke about the Planning Department guidelines for formula retail development. Formula Retail is defined as retail that has ten (11) or more stores.
• The new guidelines have been adapted from DTNA’s research and development of measuring commercial real estate saturations.
• With the new developments along the Market/Octavia corridor there will be an additional 60,000 square feet of commercial space from Octavia to Castro
• Using DTNA’s measurements Planning has established a guideline of 20% of available commercial space is allowed to be formula retail.
• Some discussion followed and it was clear that this is an issue that the community cares passionately about. Who should be supported and why? Is the guideline fair?
• It was decided that this topic will be the focus at a future EVNA Public Meeting
Chipotle
• Representatives form Chipotle presented their project proposing to move into the former space of Home restaurant on Market at Church.
• Wendy Mog from San Francisco Locally Owned Merchants Alliance (SFLOMA) spoke in opposition of Chipotle moving into this space.
• Although Chipotle is a large formula retail they try to hire locally and source locally. Chipotle claims to be e benevolent corporation that gives back charitably to the communities where they are located.
• SFLOMA discussed formula vs. Mom & Pop. With the improving economy more local retails are now moving into vacant spaces. Mom & Pop retail cannot compete with large corporate retail and formula retail drives up the rents which forces smaller retail out.
• Discussion followed
o DTNA has opposed the Chipotle move claiming they will bring the formula retail to 30% in that area
o Chipotle will be paying the same rent as was Home and will sign a the (10) year lease
o Chipotle’s Berkeley location has coexisted with local taquerias and not put anyone out of business
o Since 2006 Chipotle has not been affiliated with McDonalds
o Chipotle should present to the EVNA Planning Committee before 6/20
Discussion
• Agreed that at the July EVNA Public Meeting we would focus on the formula retail policy and guidelines
Meeting adjourned 9:00